• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

Has your disability claim been wrongfully denied or terminated? Call us today for help!  (888) 321-8131

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

OLF Ortiz Law Firm National Disability Attorneys

We appeal wrongful long term disability insurance and Social Security Disability denials.

  • ABOUT US
    • Our Team
    • Our Results
    • Areas We Serve
    • Core Values
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Administrative Appeals
    • Lawsuits
    • Lump Sum Settlement Offers
  • RESOURCES
    • Top 10 Mistakes That Will Destroy Your LTD Claim
    • Physical RFC Form
    • Mental RFC Form
    • Ultimate Appeal Checklist
    • Long Term Disability Case Study
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
  • BLOG
    • Long Term Disability Denials and Appeals
    • Medical Eligibility for Long Term Disability Claims
    • Eligibility for Long Term Disability Claims
    • Your Chances of Getting Approved for Disability Benefits
    • Additional Parts Of A Claim That Do Not Happen in Every Case
  • Search
  • CONTACT

Mobile Menu

Schedule A Free Consultation Now!

(888) 321-8131

  • ABOUT US
    • Areas We Serve
    • Client Reviews and Video Testimonials
    • Our Team
      • Nick Ortiz
    • Our Office
    • Core Values
    • Referring Attorney Program
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long Term Disability Claims
      • Administrative Appeals
      • Lawsuits
      • Lump-Sum Buyout Offers
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Request for Reconsideration
      • Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge
    • Personal Injury Claims
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
    • Long Term Disability
    • Social Security Disability
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • Cigna
    • Guardian
    • Hartford
    • Lincoln Financial
    • Matrix Absence Management
    • MetLife
    • Mutual of Omaha
    • Northwestern Mutual
    • New York Life
    • Principal
    • Prudential
    • Reliance Standard
    • Standard
    • Unum
  • RESOURCES
    • Blog
    • Free Downloads
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
    • FAQ: Long Term Disability
    • FAQ: Social Security Disability
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • Search
  • CONTACT
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
You are here: Home / Case Summaries / Court Rejects Treating Doctor Opinion In Favor of Paper Review

Court Rejects Treating Doctor Opinion In Favor of Paper Review

April 7, 2020

In Pearson-Rhoads v. Aetna Life Insurance Company, the plaintiff sued for the payment of Long Term Disability insurance benefits from the insurer of her ERISA governed plan, Aetna Life Insurance Company. The plaintiff made numerous arguments.  All were rejected by the court. Of particular note here is the plaintiff’s argument that Aetna abused its discretion by hiring its doctors to do “paper reviews” instead of deferring to the opinions of plaintiff’s treating doctors. The court rejects that argument like all of the plaintiff’s other arguments.

This is an example of how Courts are willing to reject the opinions of multiple treating physicians in favor of opinions by an insurance company doctor who did nothing more than a paper review of the claimant’s medical records.

Aetna’s reliance on the opinions of its own consultants over the opinions of Plaintiff’s treating physicians does not render its denial of benefits arbitrary and capricious. Administrators of ERISA plans are not required to defer to the opinions of a participant’s treating physicians. Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord, 538 U.S. 822, 831 (2003);Orvosh v. Program of Group Ins. for Salaried Emps. of Volkswagen of Am., Inc., 222 F.3d 123, 127-31 (3d Cir. 2000) (administrator’s denial of benefits upheld despite the opinion of claimant’s treating physician that claimant was totally disabled). Seven of Aetna’s consultants reviewed all of the medical records submitted in support of Plaintiff’s claim, including those of her treating physicians. Many of Aetna’s consultants reviewed the entire file more than once and in one instance, three times. As reflected in their reports, Aetna’s consultants considered and addressed both the subjective complaints and physical examination findings observed by Plaintiff’s treating physicians, along with their diagnoses and impressions. Moreover, Aetna’s reliance on the opinions of highlyqualified medical specialists demonstrates that its decision was reasonable.

That the conclusions of Aetna’s consultants were based on a paper review, rather than a physical examination, does not show that Aetna acted arbitrarily and capriciously. See, e.g., Dolfi v. Disability Reins. Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 584 F. Supp. 2d 709, 735 (M.D. Pa. 2008) (administrator’s paper-records review not arbitrary and capricious); Schlegel v. Life Ins. Co. of N. Am., 269 F. Supp. 2d 612, 627-28 (E.D. Pa. 2003) (administrator reasonably relied solely on a review of records by its own non-treating physicians). Because more than five months had passed between the motor vehicle accident that injured Plaintiff and her initial claim for benefits, the decision to forego an examination was reasonable. By the time Plaintiff initiated the appeal, more than a year had passed since the accident. There appeared to be little objective data to be gained by an examination. Aetna’s decision to forego an independent medical examination of Plaintiff was reasonable.

[Note: this claim was not handled by the Ortiz Law Firm. It is merely summarized here for a better understanding of how Federal Courts are handling long term disability insurance claims.]

Here is a copy of the decision in PDF: Pearson-Rhoads v. Aetna

Insurance Company: Aetna

Primary Sidebar

Top Ten Mistakes That Will Destroy Your Long Term Disability Claim

View All Resources

Kate Hauser was my attorney in my disability case recently. She was very helpful in explaining the steps, preparing for what's coming next, and calming my nerves!

Tamara D.

View All Testimonials

Complete This CONFIDENTIAL Form or Call (866) 480-3440 for a FREE Case Evaluation

0 of 350
GET HELP NOW

Practice Areas

  • Long Term Disability Insurance and ERISA Disability Insurance Claims
  • Social Security Disability Claims
  • Personal Injury Claims

Footer

Location

ORTIZ LAW FIRM
(888) 321-8131

316 S Baylen St
Ste 590
Pensacola, FL 32502
Monday - Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM Friday: 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Saturday - Sunday: Closed

Our Team

  • Nick Ortiz
  • Jessica Ortiz
  • Dawn Keller
  • Tory Nelson

Practice Areas

  • Long Term Disability Insurance and ERISA Disability Insurance Claims
  • Social Security Disability Claims
  • Personal Injury Claims
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Site Footer

©2020 Ortiz Law Firm, All Rights Reserved. Reproduced with Permission | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy