• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

Has your disability claim been wrongfully denied or terminated? Call us today for help!  (888) 321-8131

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

OLF Ortiz Law Firm National Disability Attorneys

We appeal wrongful long term disability insurance and Social Security Disability denials.

  • ABOUT US
    • Areas We Serve
    • Client Reviews and Video Testimonials
    • Our Team
      • Nick Ortiz
    • Our Office
    • Core Values
    • Referring Attorney Program
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long Term Disability
      • Administrative Appeals
      • Lawsuits
      • Lump-Sum Buyout Offers
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Request for Reconsideration
      • Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge
    • Personal Injury Claims
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
    • Long Term Disability
    • Social Security Disability
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • Cigna
    • Guardian
    • Hartford
    • Lincoln Financial
    • Matrix Absence Management
    • MetLife
    • Mutual of Omaha
    • Northwestern Mutual
    • New York Life
    • Principal
    • Prudential
    • Reliance Standard
    • Standard
    • Unum
  • RESOURCES
    • Blog
    • Free Downloads
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
    • FAQ: Long Term Disability
    • FAQ: Social Security Disability
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • Search
  • CONTACT

Mobile Menu

Schedule A Free Consultation Now!

(888) 321-8131

  • ABOUT US
    • Areas We Serve
    • Client Reviews and Video Testimonials
    • Our Team
      • Nick Ortiz
    • Our Office
    • Core Values
    • Referring Attorney Program
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long Term Disability
      • Administrative Appeals
      • Lawsuits
      • Lump-Sum Buyout Offers
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Request for Reconsideration
      • Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge
    • Personal Injury Claims
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
    • Long Term Disability
    • Social Security Disability
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • Cigna
    • Guardian
    • Hartford
    • Lincoln Financial
    • Matrix Absence Management
    • MetLife
    • Mutual of Omaha
    • Northwestern Mutual
    • New York Life
    • Principal
    • Prudential
    • Reliance Standard
    • Standard
    • Unum
  • RESOURCES
    • Blog
    • Free Downloads
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
    • FAQ: Long Term Disability
    • FAQ: Social Security Disability
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • Search
  • CONTACT
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
You are here: Home / Case Summaries / Claimant’s Failure To Apply For Social Security Disability Should Not Be Considered

Claimant’s Failure To Apply For Social Security Disability Should Not Be Considered

April 28, 2020

Case Name: Rowe v. United of Omaha Life Insurance

Court: U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee

Date of Decision: March 17, 2017

Type of Claim: Long Term Disability under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA)

Insurance Company: United of Omaha Life Insurance

Procedural history: This case was before the District Court on the Report and Recommendation (“R&R”) issued by a United States Magistrate Judge. In the R&R, the Magistrate Judge recommended that plaintiff’s Motion for Judgment on the Record be granted in part, and that defendant’s Motion for Judgment on the Administrative Record be denied. The Defendant filed an objection to the R&R, and plaintiff responded.

Issues: In the R&R, the Magistrate Judge found that defendant’s decision to deny benefits does not withstand the arbitrary and capricious standard of review and recommended that the case be remanded for further consideration. Defendant raises four objections to the R&R. The two most interesting objections were those where the defendant objected to: (1) the application of the arbitrary and capricious standard of review, and (2) the determination that plaintiff’s failure to apply for Social Security benefits is not relevant.

Holdings: (1) “Therefore, while Judge Shirley may not have directly cited to McClain, he cited other Sixth Circuit case law that makes the same point—that arbitrary and capricious review is highly deferential and that an administrator’s decision will be upheld ‘if it is the result of a deliberate, principled reasoning process and if it is supported by substantial evidence.’” The Court continued, “defendant’s argument that Judge Shirley was incorrect to base his decision on the fact that defendant did not clearly articulate in its denials which medical opinions it credited and to what extent is not well taken.” (2) “While a disability determination made by the SSA is relevant, defendant has not cited, and the Court is not aware of, any authority for the proposition that a failure to apply for benefits is similarly relevant. Furthermore, in the R&R, Judge Shirley declined to consider that plaintiff failed to apply for Social Security benefits in part because defendant ‘did not consider plaintiff’s alleged failure to file for social security benefits at the administrative level’.”

Disclaimer: This was not a case handled by disability attorney Nick A. Ortiz. The court case is summarized here to give readers a better understanding of how Federal Courts decide long term disability ERISA claims.


Here is a PDF copy of the decision: Rowe v. United of Omaha

Primary Sidebar

Top Ten Mistakes That Will Destroy Your Long Term Disability Claim

View All Resources

Mr. Ortiz and his staff are first rate, always ready to answer any questions. Compassionate and very professional. They made this experience a positive one.

Sharon D.

View All Testimonials

Complete This CONFIDENTIAL Form or Call (866) 480-3440 for a FREE Case Evaluation

0 of 350
GET HELP NOW

Practice Areas

  • Long Term Disability Insurance and ERISA Disability Insurance Claims
  • Social Security Disability Claims
  • Personal Injury Claims

Footer

Location

ORTIZ LAW FIRM
(888) 321-8131

316 S Baylen St
Ste 590
Pensacola, FL 32502
Monday - Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM Friday: 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Saturday - Sunday: Closed

Our Team

  • Nick Ortiz
  • Jessica Ortiz
  • Dawn Keller
  • Tory Nelson

Practice Areas

  • Long Term Disability Insurance and ERISA Disability Insurance Claims
  • Social Security Disability Claims
  • Personal Injury Claims
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Site Footer

©2023 Ortiz Law Firm, All Rights Reserved. Reproduced with Permission | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy