The answer to this question depends on the type of disability insurance contract you have.
Most employees have disability insurance coverage through a group plan with a private sector employer. If your employer is large enough, or if you obtained your policy through an employee organization or union, then ERISA rules and regulations come into play. According to ERISA, you must “exhaust” your administrative remedies before you can file a lawsuit. This means you must follow the terms of the insurance policy and go through each step of the appeals process directly with the insurance company. If the insurance policy states that you must file one appeal, then you may only need to file one mandatory appeal. If the insurance policy requires you to file two appeals, then you must go through two appeals before filing a lawsuit. Other insurance policies have one mandatory appeal and one “optional” appeal.
When You May Not Have to File an Appeal
There may be other situations where you do not have to file an appeal at all before filing a lawsuit. Generally, you do not need to appeal if you have an individual policy purchased directly from an insurance agent or broker, or if your policy is sponsored by a government or church employer directly (in other words, if the policy is not through a union or employee organization). In such situations, you may be entitled to file a lawsuit after your first denial.
You may have questions as to whether you are required to file an appeal, or whether you should participate in the “optional” appeal process. If you have such questions, you should immediately seek legal advice from an attorney familiar with ERISA disability cases. Please call at (850) 898-9904.