• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

Has your disability claim been wrongfully denied or terminated? Call us today for help!  (888) 321-8131

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

OLF Ortiz Law Firm National Disability Attorneys

Ortiz Law Firm is dedicated to helping people recover the disability benefits they deserve. We handle group Long Term Disability (LTD) claims, individual disability insurance policy claims, ERISA disability claims, and Social Security Disability claims.

  • ABOUT US
    • Nick Ortiz
    • Our Team
    • Case Results
    • Testimonials
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long Term Disability
      • Long Term Disability Appeals
      • Long Term Disability Lawsuits
      • Lump Sum Buyouts/Settlements
    • ERISA Disability Claims
    • Individual Disability Insurance
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Request for Reconsideration
      • Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge
    • Personal Injury Claims
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
    • Long Term Disability
    • Social Security Disability
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • View All
    • Insurance Company Tricks And Tactics
  • RESOURCES
    • Blog
    • Get Free Resources
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
    • Long Term Disability FAQs
    • Social Security Disability FAQs
    • Long Term Disability Glossary of Key Terms in a Policy
    • Long Term Disability Case Summaries
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • Search
  • CONTACT

Mobile Menu

Call us today for help!

(888) 321-8131
  • ABOUT US
    • Nick Ortiz
    • Our Team
    • Case Results
    • Testimonials
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long Term Disability
      • Long Term Disability Appeals
      • Long Term Disability Lawsuits
      • Lump Sum Buyouts/Settlements
    • ERISA Disability Claims
    • Individual Disability Insurance
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Request for Reconsideration
      • Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge
    • Personal Injury Claims
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
    • Long Term Disability
    • Social Security Disability
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • View All
    • Insurance Company Tricks And Tactics
  • RESOURCES
    • Blog
    • Get Free Resources
    • Lump Sum Disability Buyout Calculator
    • Long Term Disability FAQs
    • Social Security Disability FAQs
    • Long Term Disability Glossary of Key Terms in a Policy
    • Long Term Disability Case Summaries
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • Search
  • CONTACT
You are here: Home / Case Summary Blog / Robinson v Aetna – Claim Sent Back to Insurer to Assess Disability Under Plan’s “Any Occupation” Definition

Robinson v Aetna – Claim Sent Back to Insurer to Assess Disability Under Plan’s “Any Occupation” Definition

April 27, 2023 //  by Ortiz Law Firm//  Leave a Comment

Background of Long Term Disability Claim with Aetna

Plaintiff Laverne Robinson brought a lawsuit against Aetna Life Insurance Company (“Aetna”) and Mondelez Global LLC Employee-Paid Group Benefits Plan (“the Plan”) for unpaid long-term disability (“LTD”) benefits under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”).

Robinson was a former Mondelez employee. As an employee, she was eligible to receive disability benefits under the Plan. Aetna served as the disability claims administrator (“DCA”).

Must “Be Receiving Social Security Disability Insurance Benefits to Continue to Receive LTD Benefits Beyond 24 Months

To qualify for the Plan’s LTD benefits for more than 24 months, Robinson needed to “be receiving” Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) from the Social Security Administration (“SSA”) by the end of the initial 24 months of LTD payments.

Timeline

Robinson ceased working on April 29, 2016 due to several serious cardiac health issues, including a heart valve replacement, a stroke, atrial fibrillation (A-Fib), and a Pacemaker.

She filed for LTD benefits, and Aetna approved the application on October 28, 2016. 

Robinson later applied for Social Security Disability benefits, but that SSDI claim was not approved by the end of the initial 24 months of LTD payments, or by October 29, 2018.

However, in March 2020, the SSA awarded Robinson SSDI retroactively effective as of October 1, 2016.

Aetna Argues “Too Little Too Late”

Per Aetna’s interpretation of the Plan, SSA’s retroactive award of SSDI made no difference. They argued that because Robinson was not receiving SSDI on October 29, 2018, Robinson was ineligible for further LTD payments from Aetna.

Robinson countered that Aetna’s interpretation violates ERISA.

The Court Rules in Favor of Robinson

Because the Plan granted discretionary authority to Aetna, the court assessed Aetna’s determination under an arbitrary and capricious standard of review:

Aetna’s strict reading, however, disregards the fact that, as a result of Robinson’s retroactive award, Robinson effectively was receiving SSDI benefits by the end of October 2018. The court therefore stands by its prior conclusion: “Because the SSA concluded that she was entitled to SSDI benefits beginning October 1, 2016, she effectively became eligible for continued receipt of LTD benefits within the Plan’s 24-month window.” Robinson, 2021 WL 4206785, at *7. By common sense, when something happens retroactively, it changes the conditions of the past; the verb tense of the Plan’s provision does not alter the effect of retroactivity.

For these reasons, the Court granted Robinson’s motion for summary judgment and remanded the case to Aetna to determine whether, apart from the timing of her SSDI award, Robinson was otherwise eligible for benefits under the Plan.

Click here for a pdf copy of the Robinson v. Aetna decision.

FacebookTweetPinLinkedInPrintEmail

Category: Case Summary Blog, Long Term DisabilityTag: Aetna

Previous Post: «What Not to Say at Your Social Security Disability Hearing What Not to Say at Your Social Security Disability Hearing
Next Post: Which Doctor Should You See to Claim Long Term Disability Benefits? Which Doctor Should You See to Claim Long-Term Disability Benefits»

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Top Ten Mistakes That Will Destroy Your Long Term Disability Claim

Get Free Resources

"Completely happy with results. I wasn't getting any traction on my own, and the Ortiz Law Firm took over, had it filed and approved within 5 months."

Tim A.

View All Testimonials

Practice Areas

  • Long Term Disability
  • ERISA Disability
  • Individual Disability Insurance
  • Social Security Disability
  • Florida Personal Injury

Footer

Contact Us

316 S Baylen St., Ste 590
Pensacola, FL 32502
(888) 321-8131
[email protected]
Monday - Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Free Resources
  • Client Testimonials
  • Case Results
  • Nationwide Representation

Claims Handled

  • Long Term Disability
  • ERISA Disability
  • Individual Disability Insurance
  • Social Security Disability
  • Florida Personal Injury
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Site Footer

© 2023 Ortiz Law Firm

Sitemap | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!