• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

Has your disability claim been denied or terminated? Call (888) 321-8131 for help!

  • Mail
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
Ortiz Law Firm logo

Ortiz Law Firm | National Disability Law Firm

Ortiz Law Firm is dedicated to helping people recover the disability benefits they deserve. We handle group Long Term Disability (LTD) claims, individual disability insurance policy claims, ERISA disability claims, and Social Security Disability claims.

  • ABOUT US
    • Nick Ortiz
    • Areas We Serve
    • Our Team
    • Our Case Results
    • Client Reviews and Testimonials
  • PRACTICE AREAS
    • Long-Term Disability Insurance
      • Administrative Appeals
      • Lawsuits
      • Lump Sum Buyouts/Settlements
      • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Occupations That May Qualify
    • Social Security Disability Claims
      • Initial Applications
      • Appeal a Denial
      • Hearings Before an Administrative Law Judge
      • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Disabling Conditions
  • DISABLING CONDITIONS
  • INSURANCE CARRIERS
    • New York Life Group Benefit Solutions (Formerly Cigna)
    • Lincoln Financial
    • Reliance Standard
    • Prudential
    • The Hartford
    • The Standard
    • MetLife
    • Guardian
    • Unum
    • Insurance Company Tricks And Tactics
  • RESOURCES
    • Appeal a Long-Term Disability Denial
    • Long-Term Disability Buyout Calculator
    • eBooks, Guides, and More
    • Disability Law Blog
    • Video Library
    • Long-Term Disability Glossary
    • Abbreviations in Social Security Disability Claims
  • CONTACT

Home | Disability Case Summaries | Page 6

Disability Case Summaries

Maher v. Prudential – LTD Denial Was Not Arbitrary And Capricious

April 20, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Here, Melissa Maher (“Maher”) was Manager of Research and Development at Bonne Bell, L.L.C. (“Bonne Bell”). Her job duties were considered to be light with sedentary demand. Further requirements were the ability to use ten pounds of force and other exertions of lesser amounts more frequently. Because of her employment with Bonne Bell, Maher was …

Read moreMaher v. Prudential – LTD Denial Was Not Arbitrary And Capricious
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Prudential

Leonor v. Provident – “The Important Duties” Does Not Equal “All The Important Duties”

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

A dentist from Michigan prevailed on appeal after Provident Life and Paul Revere denied his long-term disability benefits. Although the insurers argued he wasn’t totally disabled because he could still perform managerial duties, the Sixth Circuit affirmed that he was unable to perform the primary duties of his occupation.

Read moreLeonor v. Provident – “The Important Duties” Does Not Equal “All The Important Duties”
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Provident

Lash v. Reliance Standard – Case Dismissed For Failure To State Claim Against Matrix

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Although she initially received long-term disability benefits from Reliance Standard, Lash's claim was later denied under the stricter “any occupation” standard. Lash sued both Reliance Standard and Matrix Absence Management, the plan’s third-party administrator.

Read moreLash v. Reliance Standard – Case Dismissed For Failure To State Claim Against Matrix
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Reliance Standard

Kouzmanoff v. Unum – Court Upholds Unum’s Decision To Deny Diabetes Claim

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The present case involves an ERISA claim for short-term disability and long-term disability insurance benefits where the claimant argues that the administrator improperly denied his claims for benefits. Marc Kouzmanoff (“Kouzmanoff”) was a sales representative for Thompson Reuters Holdings, Inc. (“Thompson Reuters”). In 2001, he developed diabetes; …

Read moreKouzmanoff v. Unum – Court Upholds Unum’s Decision To Deny Diabetes Claim
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Unum

Koning v. United Of Omaha – Insurer Failed To Adequately Evaluate Medical Evidence

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

In this case, the court found that United of Omaha Life Insurance Company failed to evaluate the medical evidence presented adequately. The insurer ignored favorable evidence submitted by her treating physician(s), selectively reviewed the evidence it did consider from the treating physicians, failed to conduct its own physical examination, and …

Read moreKoning v. United Of Omaha – Insurer Failed To Adequately Evaluate Medical Evidence
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Mutual of Omaha

Khalil v. Liberty Life – Surveillance Supports Long-Term Disability Claim Denial

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The Court held, “The level of activity or the lack thereof that Mr. Khalil reported to Liberty in support of his claim of continued disability was undermined by the video evidence that Liberty collected during the three years of review.” The claimant’s claim was further undermined by the fact that his own treating physicians ultimately opined that …

Read moreKhalil v. Liberty Life – Surveillance Supports Long-Term Disability Claim Denial
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Liberty Mutual

Kerridge v. United Of Omaha – Medical Evidence Does Not Support Disability

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

On May 8, 2015, United informed Kerridge’s counsel by letter that it had denied Kerridge’s appeal. United indicated that its decision was based on the records from Dr. Wilson and the Cleveland Clinic, the other records in Kerridge’s file, and Dr. Zafar’s report from the IME. Kerridge filed a civil action in Federal Court seeking review of United’s …

Read moreKerridge v. United Of Omaha – Medical Evidence Does Not Support Disability
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Mutual of Omaha

Baker v. Sun Life – Court Rules In Favor Of Insurance Company

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

In this case, Kenneth Baker (“Baker”) was an employee who worked for Dunkin Donuts. Through his employment there, he held a policy for long-term disability benefits. Unfortunately, Baker lost all of his administrative appeals with the insurance companies. He also lost at the lower Federal Court. The opinion below relates to Baker’s appeal of the …

Read moreBaker v. Sun Life – Court Rules In Favor Of Insurance Company
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Sun Life

Tyler v. American General – Psychiatrist Files Action For Bad Faith And Punitive Damages

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Here, Kelly Ann Tyler (“Tyler”) filed a claim for a breach of disability insurance contract against United States Life Insurance Company and American General Life Insurance Company (together, “American General”). Further, she filed claims for a breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing by American General, seeking punitive damages. …

Read moreTyler v. American General – Psychiatrist Files Action For Bad Faith And Punitive Damages
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: American General

Kochanek v. Aetna – Court Upholds Claim Denial Due To Lack Of Medical Evidence

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Katherine Kochanek (“Kochanek”) worked as an employee of Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (“Home Depot”). Through her employment, she was covered by the Home Depot Welfare Benefits Plan which included short term disability benefits. Aetna Life Insurance Co. (“Aetna”) served as the administrator of the Plan. Under the Plan, a “disability” is considered to be …

Read moreKochanek v. Aetna – Court Upholds Claim Denial Due To Lack Of Medical Evidence
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Aetna

Kaiser v. Mutual of Omaha – Pre-Existing Condition Exclusion Does Not Apply

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The fact that Dee was eventually diagnosed with cancer and that her shoulder pain “in retrospect” was caused by her cancer is not material to a determination of whether her medical care providers at the time of the medical treatment suspected cancer.

Read moreKaiser v. Mutual of Omaha – Pre-Existing Condition Exclusion Does Not Apply
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Mutual of Omaha

Jones v. Aetna – Court Finds Breach Of Fiduciary Duty Claim Isn’t Duplicative

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Lisa Jones submitted a claim for long-term disability benefits under an LTD Plan provided to her by Boeing. Aetna was the plan administrator; Aetna denied the LTD claim. Ms. Jones sued under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) for denial of benefits and breach of fiduciary duty. The district court (lower court) dismissed the …

Read moreJones v. Aetna – Court Finds Breach Of Fiduciary Duty Claim Isn’t Duplicative
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Aetna

Coats v. Reliance Standard – Court Finds That Benefit Calculation Is Incorrect

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Jennifer Coats (“Coats”) was employed by Cottage Health Care as a staff nurse. Through her employment, she was able to participate in an employee welfare benefit plan which included coverage for long-term disability benefits. These benefits were funded by Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company (“Reliance Standard”). More specifically, Reliance …

Read moreCoats v. Reliance Standard – Court Finds That Benefit Calculation Is Incorrect
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Reliance Standard

Doe v. Standard – Insurer’s Decision Was Based On The Wrong Occupation

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The court agreed with Doe that Standard's reliance on the DOT description of a generic "lawyer," rather than a job description that fully and accurately encompassed the material duties of Doe's specialized area of legal practice, rendered Standard's decision arbitrary and capricious.

Read moreDoe v. Standard – Insurer’s Decision Was Based On The Wrong Occupation
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: The Standard

Ingravallo v. Hartford – Second Circuit Overturns Claimant-Friendly Decision

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The Second Circuit recently ruled in favor of Hartford in a long-term disability claim involving multiple sclerosis, finding that Hartford's denial of long-term disability coverage was not arbitrary and capricious.

Read moreIngravallo v. Hartford – Second Circuit Overturns Claimant-Friendly Decision
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Hartford

Killen v. Reliance Standard – Court Finds There Was No Abuse Of Discretion

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The Court affirmed the district court’s decision granting summary judgment to Reliance Standard on the ground that it did not abuse its discretion in denying the claimant’s long-term disability benefits. In other words, the Court ruled in favor of the insurance company.

Read moreKillen v. Reliance Standard – Court Finds There Was No Abuse Of Discretion
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Reliance Standard

Campbell v. Hartford – Claim Denial Supported By Surveillance And Claimant’s Treating Physician

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The court ruled that Hartford reasonably relied on medical opinions and surveillance evidence in deeming her ineligible for continued benefits, which means Hartford’s decision to terminate LTD benefits was rationally justified and thus is not arbitrary and capricious.

Read moreCampbell v. Hartford – Claim Denial Supported By Surveillance And Claimant’s Treating Physician
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Hartford

Hans v. Unum – Court Upholds Denial Of Claim For Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

April 8, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The judge stated that, "the record, the policy, and the Parties’ arguments do not support the assertion that Plaintiff was disabled as of July 2012 (termination of LTD benefits) and August 2012 (termination of LWOP benefits). The Court, therefore, has no alternative other than to affirm Unum’s decision to deny Plaintiff’s benefits.”

Read moreHans v. Unum – Court Upholds Denial Of Claim For Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Unum

Griffin v. Hartford – Plaintiff Failed To Furnish Proof Of Loss

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

In this case, the court agreed with the district court that Hartford’s decision was reasonable and did not amount to an abuse of discretion. The record readily shows that Griffin received a fair and thorough consideration of his claim and that the available evidence reasonably supported Hartford’s conclusion.

Read moreGriffin v. Hartford – Plaintiff Failed To Furnish Proof Of Loss
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Hartford

Granville v. Aetna – Aetna’s Denial Was Arbitrary And Capricious

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Here, Aetna has engaged in multiple procedural irregularities, including conducting a self-serving paper review of the medical files based on the incorrect disability standard, relying on the opinion of a non-treating, non-examining physician without reason, and denying benefits based on inadequate information and lax investigatory procedures, as …

Read moreGranville v. Aetna – Aetna’s Denial Was Arbitrary And Capricious
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Aetna

Graham v. LINA – Court Rules LINA Must Review Claim Under Medium-Occupation Standard

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Defendant informed Plaintiff that her claim for LTD benefits was denied because the medical information provided did not support restrictions and limitations and did not demonstrate a functional loss. The plaintiff argued that she was not required to submit objective medical evidence to prove her disability.

Read moreGraham v. LINA – Court Rules LINA Must Review Claim Under Medium-Occupation Standard
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Life Insurance Company of North America (LINA)

Godmar v. Sedgwick – Decision To Deny Claim Was Arbitrary And Capricious

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

Disability benefits were paid for approximately one month and then were terminated. The termination letter acknowledged that “a medical condition may exist” but stated that “there must be objective medical information to support disability benefits” under the Plan. However, the court concluded that the decision to deny Godmar’s claim for short-term …

Read moreGodmar v. Sedgwick – Decision To Deny Claim Was Arbitrary And Capricious
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Sedgwick

Gilewski v. Provident – Substantial Evidence Supports Decision To Terminate Claim

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

After reviewing the administrative record and giving no deference to Provident’s decision to terminate benefits, the court found substantial evidence supporting Provident’s decision to terminate Gilewski’s long-term disability benefits.

Read moreGilewski v. Provident – Substantial Evidence Supports Decision To Terminate Claim
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Provident

Gailey v. LINA – Court Affirms Long-Term Disability Denial

April 7, 2020 // by Nick Ortiz

The Court held that Life Insurance considered all relevant information, including Abbey’s treatment notes, treatment notes from Plaintiff’s treaters at Philhaven, and the notes from the board-certified psychiatrist based on his peer review of Plaintiff’s medical records. The Court concluded that in light of the foregoing thorough review and …

Read moreGailey v. LINA – Court Affirms Long-Term Disability Denial
Category: Disability Case Summaries
Tags: Life Insurance Company of North America (LINA)
  • Previous
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Page 8
  • Next

Sidebar

Book cover: Top Ten Mistakes That Will DESTROY Your Long-Term Disability Claim

Free e-Book for LTD Claims

Discover the common pitfalls that can derail your long term disability claim.

Get Your Free Book

Our Clients Love Us

They are the best in everything.

Ricardo T.

See All Testimonials

Recent Posts

  • Krueger v. Reliance Standard – Illinois HR Executive Wins LTD Lawsuit Over Misapplied Pre-Existing Condition Exclusion
  • Ziegler v. Sun Life – Court Upholds Denial of Disability Benefits for Missouri Ophthalmic Technician
  • Halleron v. Reliance Standard – Baptist Healthcare Physician’s LTD Claim Sent Back for Full Review After Flawed Denial
  • Ortiz Law Firm Helps Client Recover Denied LTD Benefits After Cardiac Arrest and Brain Injury
  • Ward v. Reliance Standard – Maryland Engineer Wins Long-Term Disability Lawsuit

Contact Us

Ortiz Law Firm is a national disability law firm specializing in long-term disability appeals, disability insurance lawsuits, and Social Security Disability claims. Contact us for a free case review.

(888) 321-8131
316 S Baylen St., Ste 590,
Pensacola, FL 32502

  • Mail
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Claims We Handle

  • Group Long-Term Disability
  • ERISA Disability Claims
  • Individual Disability Insurance
  • Social Security Disability Claims
  • Long-Term Care Insurance

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Nick Ortiz
  • Free Resources
  • Video Library
  • Client Testimonials
  • Successful LTD Appeals
  • Nationwide Representation
  • Refer a Case

Our Pensacola Office


Sitemap | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 | Ortiz Law Firm | All Rights Reserved