Tobin v. Unum – Court Awards “Own Occupation” Disability Benefits for Intractable Headaches but Rejects the “Any Occupation” Claim
Mary Rose Tobin stopped working as an account executive after she woke up with what she called the “worst headache of [her] life,” a pain that never resolved. The court delivered a split decision: it found she could not perform her own demanding occupation, but it agreed with Unum Life Insurance Company of America that …