If you are receiving long-term disability benefits and feeling worn down by constant monitoring, requests for updated records, and ongoing scrutiny, you may have considered asking your insurance company to buy out your remaining benefits. Before you do, there are serious risks you need to understand.
What Is an LTD Buyout, and How Does It Differ from a Settlement?
A buyout occurs when an insurance company that is actively paying your benefits agrees to pay a single lump sum in exchange for terminating the policy as to your claim. You receive the money; the insurance company is done paying. A settlement, by contrast, typically occurs in the context of litigation — where the insurer has already denied or terminated benefits and you have filed a lawsuit to recover them.
The distinction matters because the financial outcomes are very different. In a buyout where benefits are currently being paid, claimants may receive somewhere between 50% and 85% of the present value of their future benefits. In a litigation settlement, that figure drops substantially — often to around 25% to 33% — because the insurer does not believe they owe anything and is paying to avoid the cost and uncertainty of further litigation.
Why Does Initiating a Buyout Request Put Your Benefits at Risk?
When a claimant asks the insurance company for a buyout, the insurance company immediately becomes suspicious. They typically consider two explanations: that the claimant’s medical condition has improved significantly, or that the claimant is planning to return to work and wants to cash out before losing eligibility.
Either interpretation gives the insurer a reason to open a fresh investigation. That investigation can involve social media monitoring, LinkedIn profile reviews, public business records searches, and requests for updated medical records. If the insurance company says no to the buyout — which is the most common outcome — your claim may now be under a level of scrutiny it would not otherwise have faced.
What Happens After Most Buyout Requests?
Most of the time, the insurance company simply declines. They are currently paying a monthly benefit and have no incentive to write a large check today when they can continue paying over time — especially if they expect the claimant’s condition to change or benefits to end for other reasons.
In some cases, particularly with older claimants who have fewer remaining benefit years, the insurer may be open to negotiating. But even when negotiations are possible, they are complicated by the need to calculate present value, account for potential future adjustments, and evaluate what percentage of that value the insurer is willing to offer.
How Is a Buyout Amount Calculated?
The starting point is calculating the present value of your remaining future benefits — essentially what all future monthly payments would be worth in today’s dollars, accounting for the time value of money. From that figure, an insurance company will typically offer a percentage.
In an active-payment buyout scenario, that percentage generally lands somewhere between 50% and 85% of the present value calculation. There is no fixed formula, and outcomes depend on factors like your age, the number of benefit years remaining, your medical history, and the insurer’s own assessment of how long they expect to continue paying. An attorney experienced in LTD claims can help you run the numbers and evaluate any offer you receive.
If you’ve been presented with a buyout offer, Ortiz Law Firm can review it — and in some cases, we’ve been able to negotiate a higher amount than what the insurer initially offered.
When Might a Buyout Actually Make Sense?
There are situations where a buyout is worth exploring — for instance, when a claimant has a compelling reason to need a lump sum, when the remaining benefit period is short enough that ongoing scrutiny outweighs the value of continued monthly payments, or when the relationship with the insurer has become genuinely unmanageable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I negotiate a higher buyout amount than the insurance company’s initial offer?
Yes, initial offers are often negotiable. The key is understanding the present value of your remaining benefits and the percentage the insurer is applying. An attorney experienced in LTD buyouts can help you evaluate the offer, challenge an unreasonably low figure, and push for a better outcome without jeopardizing your ongoing benefits.
Is the lump sum from an LTD buyout taxable?
Tax treatment of LTD buyout proceeds depends on how your premiums were paid. If your employer paid the premiums and you did not include them in taxable income, the buyout proceeds are typically taxable. If you paid the premiums with after-tax dollars, proceeds may be tax-free. Consult a tax professional for advice specific to your situation.
Add Ortiz Law Firm as a preferred source on Google »
